Poultry

Smoked Turkey Breast with Butter Rest

A deboned, skinless turkey breast with an olive oil binder and Holy Cow, smoked at 200–250°F to 160°F, then wrapped and rested with butter for an hour. Beats deli meat any day.

Prep
20 minutes
Cook
2½–3 hours
Total
About 4 hours
Yield
6–8 servings
Method
Smoked
Wood
Your choice

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Take the breast off the ribs, debone it and remove the skin. Try to keep the tenderloins attached.
  2. Coat with a little olive oil and season all over with Holy Cow.
  3. Smoke at 200°F, then bump the smoker to 250°F. Cook until the thickest part reaches 160°F, about 2½–3 hours.
  4. Lay out a sheet of foil, add the butter, set the turkey on top and wrap tightly.
  5. Rest for 1 hour. Carryover heat brings it to 165°F.
  6. Slice against the grain and spoon the buttery juices over the top.

Pitmaster Notes

  • Always confirm 165°F after the rest. Poultry needs to hit it for safety.
  • If your breast isn't pre-brined, a brine makes it juicier and lets you control the salt.
  • Another way I make it: olive oil, black pepper and The Gospel, smoked at 225°F to about 165°F (2–3 hours), then rested with butter for an hour.
  • A bigger, thicker breast cooks more evenly. Small tenderloins cook fast and the rub can overpower them.

Times and temps are my starting points. Every cooker and every cut runs a little different, so cook to temperature and feel, not the clock.